Is a Harness Better than a Collar for a Dog?

Choosing between a dog collar and a good harness seems simple at first. If you research a little more, you’ll find out that both options deeply affect your dog’s overall well-being, comfort, safety, and daily life. 

So, most dog parents have the same concern: are dog harnesses better than collars? The realistic answer remains: the best option always depends on the behavior of your dog, his body shape, walking style, and health status. 

Well, both resources are widely used across Australia. About 72% of dog owners use both a harness and a collar for different situations, says a 2024 industry report. It further states that over 55% of people like to have a harness for daily walks. 

It’s because of the added control and reduced strain. It's clear that both tools have their own place. Your role as a pet parent is to know and understand where each one shines. 

The good news is that the market for dog collars, harnesses, and leashes continues to grow. We have prepared this guide for you to help you take better care of your dog. 

This post breaks down the differences to help you choose the right walking gear for your dearest friend. 

Dog Collars are a Common and Popular Option

The use of dog collars is not new. They are widely available as they are easy and convenient, in a myriad of colours, materials, and designs. ID tags cannot be left without collars, as they are essential for pet security, many councils in Australia require pets to wear collars at all times.

One of the primary advantages of collars is convenience. You can leave them on your dog all day without any inconvenience. You can use them with well-behaved kids who do not pull a lot.

Advantages of Dog Collars

• Easy to use for daily wear

• Necessary to contain registration and ID tags

• Lightweight and easy to carry around by the free-roaming dogs

• Excellent in quick connection with the leash

Not every dog will be happy in a collar. There are also hard pullers, dogs with breathing difficulties, and dogs with weak necks. To such dogs, a collar can put pressure on the neck and cause them to cough and feel uncomfortable when walking.

Which Dogs Should Use a Collar?

A collar may be the appropriate solution in the case when your dog has the proper temperament and physical condition Collars can be worn by:

1. Dogs That Walk Calmly on Leash

A collar is just fine in case your dog does not pull so much. Such dogs are obedient, accompany you, and walk at a steady speed.

2. Dogs that don’t Have Breathing Problems

Dogs with healthy airways, such as the Greyhounds, Labradors or other breeds, can wear collars without difficulty. However, breeds at greater risk of respiratory issues include brachycephalic breeds, such as Pugs and French Bulldogs.

3. Dogs Trained for Obedience

In case your dog is obedient and prefers to have a structure, a collar would be very appropriate when he is going on a short walk, and the route to be taken is predictable.

4. Dogs That Need an ID Holder

A collar can be used to add identification tags, even with a harness; even without a leash, your dog may need a collar when he is at home or in an off-leash dog park.

A collar is used when your dog has proper walking behaviour and a strong neck. Otherwise, a harness would be more comfortable and safe.

Dog Harnesses are a Comfortable Alternative

Harnesses has gained popularity among the active Australian pet owners. A harness evenly distributes pressure across the shoulders and the chest of the dog, and puts less pressure on the neck. It comes in most handy with puppies, heavy pullers, or excited dogs that tug on walks.

Harness also provides greater control for the owners and it is best suited to areas with a lot of traffic, open spaces, or coastal walks; these are very common in Australia.

Advantages of Dog Harnesses

• Reduces pressure on the dog’s neck and throat

• Offers more control for owners

• Ideal for training dogs that pull

• Comfortable for long walks, hikes, and outdoor activities

• Better for dogs with medical or structural issues

Harnesses such as DOOG’s Australian weather-based range feature breathable, fast-drying materials and ergonomic designs.

Which Dogs Should Use a Harness?

Harnesses are suitable for a wide variety of dogs and for many, they’re the preferred choice.

1. Dogs That Pull or Lunge

If your dog pulls hard, a harness is gentler and safer. It helps guide your dog without choking or putting pressure on the trachea.

2. Puppies in Training

Young dogs who are learning leash manners benefit greatly from harnesses. The chest-based pressure helps you steer them more clearly.

3. Dogs With Neck, Spine, or Breathing Issues

Harnesses protect sensitive areas, making them ideal for small breeds, brachycephalic dogs, and senior dogs.

4. Active Dogs

If your dog joins you for hikes, beach runs, outdoor adventures, and weekend trips, a harness offers better stability.

5. Escape Artists

Dogs who slip out of collars - especially thin or flexible-necked breeds are often safer in a well-fitted harness.

Dog Collar vs Harness: So… Which One is Better?

Your choice between a dog harness or collar depends entirely on your dog’s behaviour and lifestyle. Ask yourself a few simple questions:

• Does my dog pull firmly on walks?

• Does my dog have a short snout or breathing sensitivity?

• Do we take long outdoor adventures?

• Do I need more control during busy streets or crowded places?

• Is identification required at all times?

If you answered “yes” to most of the above, a harness is almost always the better option. On the other hand, if your dog is calm, trained, and only goes on short walks, then a collar might be excellent.

Most dog owners today use both tools - a collar for ID and indoor time, and a harness for walks. This combination gives your dog comfort, safety, and flexibility.

Conclusion: Get Your Mate the Best Care Possible

So, you read about the common concern: are harnesses better for dogs? Many people believe that these are a better option for their dogs as harnesses offer improved support, greater control, and less pressure on the dog’s sensitive areas. 

Harnesses can be a go-to choice for active dogs, pullers, puppies, and breeds with respiratory problems. Collars still serve the same important purpose, but they are different in how they make your dog feel or live by. Collars are suitable for identification and calm walkers. 

Select your option, prioritizing your dog’s health. Think of the support that keeps them more comfortable and makes your daily walks enjoyable. Make your dog feel safe, secure, and happy on every day adventure with the right fit - whether a collar, harness, or both.